Welsh Health Minister orders inquiry into baby death at Ystrad Mynach Hospital

THE Welsh health minister tonight ordered an inquiry after a woman's baby died while she waited two hours for an ambulance for an emergency caesarean section.

The woman is understood to have been at Ysbyty Ystrad Fawr in Ystrad Mynach and had been waiting for an ambulance to the Royal Gwent Hospital when the incident took place last Thursday.

Health minister Lesley Griffiths was reacting to comments made by Plaid AM Jocelyn Davies in the Assembly about the case.

Ms Davies asked for a reaction from Ms Griffiths about a Caerphilly woman who last week waited two hours for an ambulance to take her from Ystrad Mynach to the Royal Gwent Hospital where her baby then died during an attempted forceps delivery.

She asked the minister: “Will you ensure that the family’s wishes for a proper investigation are met?

“Will women have confidence in midwife-led centres if they have no confidence in an ambulance should things go wrong?”

Ysbyty Ystrad Fawr, run by Gwent's Aneurin Bevan Health Board, has a midwifery-led birthing unit.

Ms Griffiths responded saying she was aware of the case: “I can assure you I will be writing to the Aneurin Bevan Health Board to ensure a thorough investigation."

Ms Davies raised the matter during a debate on Wales' ambulance service, called by the Liberal Democrats, in the Senedd on Wednesday evening.

Comments(9)

richie55 says...
7:33pm Wed 7 Nov 12

Sad case but we do not need an inquiry to discover what we all know to be the problem....too many people call for an ambulance when they could make other arrangements and there are just not enough ambulances to go around. I had a heart attack in a shop in Newport City centre and had to wait over 30 minutes for an ambulance to arrive and on the way to the RGH the driver was told to take me to Nevill Hall in Abergavenny as the RGH was full. This was at 3pm on a Wednesday afternoon !

Aquarius says...
9:47pm Wed 7 Nov 12

My condolences to the lady concerned and her family.

Yes, it comes down to the ever-increasing demand for ambulances (not all justified, as the previous person correctly stated) and totally inadequate resources.

More ambulance crews needed and therefore, REALISTIC FUNDING.

Still, I suppose there will be the usual facile statement from an Ambulance Service director, an internal investigation and then a search for someone - probably in Ambulance Control - who can be made a scapegoat. Again.

Note to the Welsh Government: when you finally decide to fund the Ambulance Service properly, make sure the Service has senior managers at the top who are capable of spending the money properly. I don't think there's many of the current lot that fit the bill, but they're very proficient at coming up with excuses and people lower down to blame.

maryring says...
9:47pm Wed 7 Nov 12

So sad, this situation could of been easily avoided if an ambulance came as requested. My heart goes out the the mother and father who must be totally heartbroken along with the rest of the family. Bitterly let down by the Health Service and this is totally unacceptable !! Sickening !!!

BLACKIE2012 says...
11:33pm Wed 7 Nov 12

Its disgusting in this day and age that this as happened we cant even say we are going back in time as the NHS was a far better service then. My heart goes out to the parents who have been looking forward to their baby. How the people responsible can sleep in the nights I never know. What are taxpayers paying for?? The Health Service is a disgrace!!

FreeWorld says...
6:43am Thu 8 Nov 12

My heart goes out to the poor family....heartbreak
ing. Although further questions need to be asked. If the mother waited 2 hours for an ambulance so that she could have an 'emergency' c-section @ RGH......why did on arrival @ RGH did they attempt a forceps delivery?????

signal box says...
8:28am Thu 8 Nov 12

I would wish to extend my condolences to the family at this very sad time.
But the minister must accept that they must have a root and branch restructure of the Welsh Ambulance Service the amalganation of NHS Direct and Welsh Ambulance Service was a huge mistake lets follow the trend and get rid of NHS Direct don't let these staff take over the management of the Ambulance Service also get rid of the managers such as Retired Police Officers who have been imported to run the service. Aquarius is correct the management will carry out an investigation and then hang out to dry a junior member of staff.

Templar05 says...
4:23pm Thu 8 Nov 12

First of all , I am sorry that a child died and my heart goes out to the family .
I am going to agree with Richie 55 . I worked in the A and E department for 3 years and I seen people arriving in ambulances like they were taxis and leaving the hospital in a cab .Paramedics use to tell me that when they worked a 12 hour shift , they rarely had a tea break . Keep up the good work everyone, at the RGH .

snowy0211 says...
7:40pm Thu 8 Nov 12

Horrific story. I will say that it is not just the ambulance service but the general care and response from Gwent Hospital which is autrocious. My Partner waited an hour and a half to be seen by a midwife after transfer for signs of preeclampsia. The midwife from the gwent then decided this was not a major issue until a doctor came to assess and issued an emergency C section. My son was born traumatised and struggling for life. Thankfully this was resolved very quickly and we now have a son whos recovering well

Bobevans says...
9:29am Fri 9 Nov 12

In England they have idetified from their monitoring that they have started to see minor problems with Ambulances being delayed by Hospitals refuseing to accept patients sothat they can meet their targets. They put a stop to that by saying they had to accept a patient on arrival.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree