Report this comment
  • "
    BassalegCountyFan wrote:
    Llanmartinangel wrote:
    BassalegCountyFan wrote:
    Llanmartinangel wrote:
    BassalegCountyFan wrote:
    On a national level, why don't we remove the charitable status on private schools so that they pay their fair share like the rest of us to improve the education of the majority. Just a thought.
    Wouldn't that mean that the fees would go up in private schools? If less people could afford them you'd have to find places for them in the state system with the attendent additional cost so it's just pointless. The people paying twice for their kids education (they pay their taxes too) aren't what's wrong with failing state schools.
    Actually we - the taxpayers - effectively lose £100 million a year to subsidise the charitable status of private schools. Bearing in mind that only 7% of children in Britain attend these schools, can we really afford to give wealthy parents who send their children to such institutions what equates to a £200 a year tax subsidy? More so, do private schools behave like charities to justify this status? I don't think so.
    It's daft beyond belief.

    Perhaps we could put that £100 million towards something more useful - reintroducing EMA. Perhaps average PISA scores would rise if large numbers of children- that's those who are part of the whopping 93% whose mummies and daddies can't afford to splash ther cash on a posh education - didn't have to worry about costs of travelling to school, purchasing books etc. Just a thought!
    All the people I know who send their kids to fee schools, both parents work and make sacrifices to afford it. They choose to prioritise their children's education over other things. Good for them. The idea that all of them have mansions and shoot grouse is outdated class warrior tripe.
    I'm afraid I don't know anyone who sent their children to fee-paying schools (I don't think they'd want to lower themselves to associate with serfs like myself!) so can't comment. I'm sure some are hard-working (if misguided) people. The real issue though, is why we should subsidise the charity status on their schools at the expense of the education of the non-private school educated majority.
    And as for 'outdated tripe', check out the recent ramblings of old Etonian Boris Johnson on how inequality exists because of the low IQ's of the masses (before failing a basic IQ test a few days later). I bet his mam and dad would be proud of the thousands they splashed on his education!
    I'm not sure why someone spending their own money on their kids education could be termed 'misguided' but hey, to each his/her own. As for bicycle obsessed Boris, true, but then I'd be as disinclined to quote him as I would his newt-fancying, hypocrite, tax avoiding predecessor."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Wales still worst in UK in global school tests

Campaign Series: Wales still worst in UK in global school tests Wales still worst in UK in global school tests

WALES is still the worst performing UK nation for maths, science and reading, according to an international league table released today.

Every three years the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) surveys around half a million students from across 65 countries which are part of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).

Can you do the PISA test? Try it here by clicking the link at the foot of the page.

The last series of tests, which took place in 2009 and were wholly separate from standard exams such as GCSEs, focused on reading and ranked the UK 25th behind Denmark, France, Ireland, Germany, Liechtenstein, Estonia, Poland and Korea.

In 2009 Wales rated the lowest of the UK nations in reading, maths and science.

Three years on, with the emphasis on maths, Welsh PISA test results for maths and science in 2012 were worse than 2009, but reading had improved slightly.

England had improved in all three categories, while Scotland improved in both maths and reading but dipped in science, and Northern Ireland also performed worse in all three categories.

The UK average has either remained the same or improved in maths, reading and science, but the UK is now ranked 26th among OECD countries in the 2012 performance table.

Speaking at a meeting of the Institute of Welsh Affairs Gwent branch in Cross Keys last week, the director of school standards in Welsh Government, Dr Brett Pugh said of the Welsh education system: “I agree, it’s a system that’s not performing as well as it should.”

Yesterday the Conservative shadow minister for education Angela Burns AM claimed the results would determine whether Labour is on course to meet its 2015 target of Wales being in the top 20 of all OECD nations.

Robert Lloyd Griffiths, director of the Institute of Directors (IOD) in Wales described the results as “bitterly disappointing” and blamed historic complacency in the UK.

Education and Skills Minister Huw Lewis said the results were "disappointing" and showed Wales still "got a way to go before we close the gap with the OECD’s best performing countries".

He added: "There are signs of some progress in reading, but significant improvement was never likely at this stage.

"Everybody working in and around the Welsh Education sector needs to take a long hard look in the mirror this week. The PISA results are stark and the message is very clear, we must improve educational attainment and standards right across the board.

"I am confident that the measures we’ve put in place since the last set of PISA results are the right way forward for Wales and we won’t be distracted from delivering them. Today’s news simply reinforces our case for the ambitious reforms we have already developed and everyone across the education sector in Wales now needs to play their part."

LIVE COVERAGE OF REACTION TO WALES' PISA RESULTS: Can you do the PISA test? Try it here

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree