Report this comment
  • "
    Rus rage Smith wrote:
    NakedDancer wrote:
    vertidog wrote:
    Woodgnome you make these comments which clearly reflect your opinion which is fine. The issue i have is that as stated this was one punch in a 30 man brawl. Does this mean that every person who throws a punch on the rugby field is guilty of "thuggery" and should in your view not play game again?? If that's the case there would be no-one left to play!
    I feel this sets a dangerous precedence and could possibly open the flood gates for all kinds of allegations on the field of play. The fact is that out of the thirty odd players fighting Rhys was the only one to cause significant injury with one single blow. In the same incident three Cardiff players set upon one Crosskeys player. Is this not a worse case of "thuggery"??
    Despite the comments made by the media and commentators the brutal fact is that violence in sport is glorified in one breath then condemned in the next.
    Is this worse than Bradley Davies being knocked unconscious by Andrew Hore in an unprovoked attack from behind in an international match at the Millennium stadium? IS it worse than Ian Evans stamping on someone's face? Broad sweeping statements such as yours need to be supported with some facts!
    Regarding the sentence the frustration lies in the lack of consistency, when Billy Burglar burgles ten house and walks away with community service and heroin drug dealers receive a suspended sentence then how can this sentence be justified.
    I admit i am a family member of Rhys but i am attempting to remove the emotion and speak of the facts.
    The fact is Rhys pleaded guilty at the earliest opportunity therefore reducing cost to the tax player and removing the stress which would have been put on the player who would have had to relive the incident in court. He apologized sincerely and also the judge accepted that he did not intend to cause such injury compensation was also offered and also the probation service recommended community hours and a suspended sentence and yet unbelievably he was given this sentence.
    I look forward to your response.
    "Does this mean that every person who throws a punch on the rugby field is guilty of thuggery" - obviously yes.

    "sets a dangerous precedence and could possibly open the flood gates for all kinds of allegations on the field of play" - not a precedent as the law of assault has always been clear and plenty of rugby players have been charged and punished in the past. Rugby is not above the law.

    "of the thirty odd players fighting Rhys was the only one to cause significant injury" - obviously thats why he was charged.

    If you want to argue others should have been charged in this game (or other matches) or the sentence was too harsh then maybe. However, if you assault someone you face the consequences.
    You have clearly never played rugby before as everyone knows when in a punch up of over 30 men, the only thing you can do is defend yourself. its unfortunate that the boy rhys punched had injuries, but that could have happened to any of the players involved.
    The fact is rhys didnt chase after the boy or repeatedly hit him! he threw a punch just the same as everyone else.
    For all who knows rhys, Hes a tough guy who can look after himself, but he is and always has been a gentleman and would never have thrown the punch to cause serious damage. the sentence he has been given is extremely harsh!
    I've played at a very high level but thats irrelevant. Rhys didn't claim it was self defence and I'm sure his lawyer, the CPS and court considered whether it was self defence. If you assault and seriously injure someone you pay the price and its the same law on a rugby pitch as a pub brawl. It's irrelevant if you are a nice guy and didn't mean to cause the damage that you did. Thats the law."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.

  • Enter the above word in the box below

Cross Keys rugby player Rhys Peebles jailed for punching opponent after match

Cross Keys rugby player jailed for punching opponent after match

JAILED: Rhys Peebles

'HUGE BRAWL': Rhys Peebles

First published in News
Last updated

A CROSS Keys rugby player has been jailed for a year after a punch he threw during a “huge” end-of-game brawl left a fellow player in need of 28 stitches.

Back row forward Rhys Peebles, 30, was sentenced for malicious wounding and inflicting grievous bodily harm at Cardiff Crown Court on Tuesday.

The incident took place on November 29 last year, during the dying minutes of the Principality Premiership away game against Cardiff RFC at Cardiff Arms Park.

Callum Lewis, from Merthyr, was left with a nasty cut below his eye and only returned to action last week, said a Cardiff RFC spokesman after the hearing.

In mitigation, Jonathan Wellington said Peebles, who was sent off for throwing the punch, had lashed out “in the heat of the moment”.

“There was a huge brawl and everything happened so quickly that, in his mind, he thought the other player was moving towards the brawl and he lashed out. Obviously that blow landed.”

Mr Lewis, 20, is said to have made a full recovery and is currently playing for Wales Under-20s.

But Peebles, of Pontywaun, was handed a 12-month custodial sentence on Tuesday and was ordered to pay a victim surcharge of £120.

He pleaded guilty at a preliminary hearing on January 7.

Cross Keys won the game against Cardiff 38-10, to make it six straight competitive wins up to that point.

Peebles, said on the Cross Keys RFC website to be a carpenter, is listed as 6ft 2in tall and weighing 16-and-a-half stones.

He lists past clubs as Abercarn, but has played for Cross Keys since 2005.

His best season came in the 2011/12 campaign when he was on the winning side for 20 out of the 29 games he played, scoring 15 points.

Comments (109)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree