Historic derby ends in a draw with little for fans to cheer

PACE: Newport’s Adam Davies on the attack against Cardiff during tonight’s derby clash at Rodney Parade

PACE: Newport’s Adam Davies on the attack against Cardiff during tonight’s derby clash at Rodney Parade

First published in Gwent rugby Campaign Series: Photograph of the Author by

NEWPORT 6 CARDIFF 6

NEWPORT failed to avenge Cardiff’s 62-17 hammering of them back in September but at least they prevented their old enemy recording the double over them.

To be frank, this was a bitterly disappointing derby draw that was probably the right result.

It could have been the Black Friday effect, but there was a disappointingly small crowd at Rodney Parade to witness the latest chapter of this historic rivalry between the two famous clubs.

It’s now sadly something of a sideshow in the grand scheme of things, thanks to regional rugby’s (not so grand) new frontier.

That the game ever took place was testament to the wonderful work carried out by the ground staff.

But conditions, after days of heavy rain, made for plenty of handling errors that marred proceedings.

That said, there was plenty of full-blooded commitment on show by both teams but not much for the spectators to cheer.

Newport started the stronger and edged the territorial kicking game before their former Cardiff outside half Scott Sneddon drew first blood with a well struck penalty after 12 minutes.

But that lead was short lived when his counterpart Will Thomas brought the Blue and Blacks back on level terms with a sweetly struck drop goal.

The game ebbed and flowed with little of note until the 28th minute when Cardiff’s Simon Gardiner was yellow carded, the ex-Scarlets tighthead prop sent to the sin bin for going in far too high on Sneddon in an attempted tackle.

Newport failed to take advantage against the 14 men of the capital city side, their only chance of scoring came when their forwards lost the ball driving over the visitors’ try-line.

And a Thomas penalty, the last kick of a quite uneventful first half, put Cardiff in a deserved 6-3 lead, the visitors’ backs sharper and more dangerous than the home side’s.

The second half wasn’t much better as both sides failed to build any momentum or pattern to their game.

And the home fans weren’t shy in expressing their contempt for referee Jonathan Mason, feeling they were on the wrong end of several of his decisions.

Newport were fortunate that Thomas missed two kickable penalties that would have taken them even further ahead.

And it was the Black and Ambers who drew level with ten minutes to go when Sneddon kicked his second shot at goal.

They could have taken the lead when a lovely midfield move saw centre Dan Robinson go through a gap in the dying minutes only for the former Pontypool man to knock the ball on in the Cardiff 22.

The game fizzled out and at the final whistle most fans couldn’t possibly be blamed for erasing an eminently forgettable encounter from their memory banks.

Newport scorers: Penalties – Scott Sneddon (2)

Cardiff scorers: Penalty – Will Thomas, drop goal – Will Thomas

Referee: Jonathan Mason (WRU)

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:13am Sat 22 Dec 12

Euwan Usami says...

Couldn't decide which was worse really, the constant banging from the silmutaniously held parties (plural) at RP while the game was on, the miserable freezing weather, the teams half @rsed attempts at playing, the equally half @rsed attempts to control the PA system. (Either silent during announcements or interval music continuing into match time and competing with said party music) or the freaking referee! It's possible I just wasn't in the mood tonight. ;)
Couldn't decide which was worse really, the constant banging from the silmutaniously held parties (plural) at RP while the game was on, the miserable freezing weather, the teams half @rsed attempts at playing, the equally half @rsed attempts to control the PA system. (Either silent during announcements or interval music continuing into match time and competing with said party music) or the freaking referee! It's possible I just wasn't in the mood tonight. ;) Euwan Usami
  • Score: 0

12:38am Sat 22 Dec 12

Robert Shillabeer says...

A poor performance from both sides supported by a rather poor performance by the ref. Lucky to be a draw for both sides. Numerous unforced errors such as knock-ons when openings presented themselves and very poor handling the rest of the time. Predictable play for eighty minutes supported by a poor game management and non existant thought. Dissapointed could have gone shopping and enjoyed it more.
A poor performance from both sides supported by a rather poor performance by the ref. Lucky to be a draw for both sides. Numerous unforced errors such as knock-ons when openings presented themselves and very poor handling the rest of the time. Predictable play for eighty minutes supported by a poor game management and non existant thought. Dissapointed could have gone shopping and enjoyed it more. Robert Shillabeer
  • Score: 0

12:14pm Sat 22 Dec 12

fedupjon says...

Iwan's report was actually a massive improvement on the very poor game but I do have to take issue on one point.
He seems to suggest the pitch conditions were poor but he is wrong. The problem was the total lack of basic skills on both sides.
Whoever is the skills coaches should take a long hard look at themselves.
If the premiership is the breeding ground for the regions and then Wales, god help us in future years.
Iwan's report was actually a massive improvement on the very poor game but I do have to take issue on one point. He seems to suggest the pitch conditions were poor but he is wrong. The problem was the total lack of basic skills on both sides. Whoever is the skills coaches should take a long hard look at themselves. If the premiership is the breeding ground for the regions and then Wales, god help us in future years. fedupjon
  • Score: 0

9:29pm Sat 22 Dec 12

foxy3rd says...

Personally I thought that the Carediff handling was much slicker especially the backs.A couple of Npt boy's stood out but not enough,though overall commitment was good.A couple of the Newport team don't look good enough for this level.Touchjudges very iffy at times yet again.
Personally I thought that the Carediff handling was much slicker especially the backs.A couple of Npt boy's stood out but not enough,though overall commitment was good.A couple of the Newport team don't look good enough for this level.Touchjudges very iffy at times yet again. foxy3rd
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree